We are living in a world without a single treaty limiting the number of strategic nuclear weapons—the threat of proliferation is again at our doorstep. Are we in a new nuclear arms race? Will the world see an increase in nuclear-armed states in the coming years? What is distinct about this strategic nuclear environment?
This Ethics Empowered: Leadership in Practice convening on the new debate around nuclear weapons was moderated by Kathleen Egan, Carnegie Council’s senior program associate and nuclear ethics programming lead.
Resources
Carnegie Council Activity on Nuclear Complacency: The Officer’s Dilemma, Carnegie Council Classroom Resource, 2026
Nuclear Complacency, Kathleen Egan & Joel H. Rosenthal, Carnegie Council, November 3, 2025
"Ethics on Film: Discussion of A House of Dynamite," Kathleen Egan, Carnegie Council, October 4, 2025
"Nuclear Ethics," Values & Interests, Carnegie Council, May 22, 2026
"Walking a fraying nuclear tightrope," Joel H. Rosenthal, Politico, September 25, 2024
"Nuclear Ethics Revisited," Joseph S. Nye, Jr., Ethics & International Affairs, Carnegie Council, April 25, 2023
Nuclear deterrence, Carnegie Council Key Term, 2023
Discussion Questions
- What are examples and lessons learned from history that can help move conversations of restraint, diplomacy, and disarmament forward? What are examples from history in which restraint or diplomacy broke down and did not work?
- What could a trilateral nuclear treaty between Russia, China, and the United States look like? What are some areas of common interest that the three nations could build on to establish nuclear weapons limits?
- The regulation, treaty, and oversight regimes for nuclear weapons are expansive and robust. Are there elements that can be replicated to govern AI, a global technology that remains completely unregulated?
Carnegie Council for Ethics in International Affairs is an independent and nonpartisan nonprofit. The views expressed within this panel are those of the speakers and do not necessarily reflect the position of Carnegie Council.

